Passkeys replace a traditional password with a cryptographic key pair tied to your device and biometrics — no password to type, guess, or leak in a breach. They’re spreading fast across major sites, which raises a fair question: do you still need a password manager?
How a passkey works
When you create a passkey, your device generates two linked keys. The public key is sent to the website and stored with your account; the private key never leaves your device or your password manager. Each time you sign in, the site sends a one-time challenge, your device signs it with the private key after you confirm with a fingerprint, face scan or PIN, and the site checks the signature with the public key.
The standards behind this are FIDO2 and WebAuthn, developed by the FIDO Alliance and the W3C and supported by Apple, Google and Microsoft. Because the site only ever stores a public key, a database breach on its side gives attackers nothing they can log in with.
What passkeys solve
Passkeys can’t be phished the way a typed password can, since there’s no shared secret to trick you into revealing. They also can’t be reused across a breach the way a leaked password can.
A passkey is also bound to the real website it was created for. Even a pixel-perfect fake login page on a look-alike domain can’t request it, which removes the most common way accounts are stolen today.
What they don’t solve yet
Not every site supports passkeys, and syncing them across devices and operating systems is still inconsistent between Apple, Google and Microsoft’s implementations. Most people will run passwords and passkeys side by side for years.
Other practical gaps to know about:
- Account recovery. Many sites still fall back to a password or an email link if you lose access to your passkey, so the weaker method remains part of your account.
- Moving between ecosystems. Passkeys saved in one platform’s keychain don’t always travel easily to another. The FIDO Alliance is working on a standard way to export and import them, but support is still rolling out.
- Shared accounts. Sharing a passkey with a family member or colleague depends entirely on the app that stores it.
Where a password manager still wins
A password manager stores both passwords and passkeys in one place, works everywhere passkeys aren’t yet supported, and adds features like breach monitoring and secure sharing that passkeys alone don’t offer. Bitwarden, 1Password and NordPass all support storing passkeys today — see our full rating for the full breakdown.
The big advantage of keeping passkeys in a cross-platform manager rather than an operating-system keychain is independence: the same passkey works on your Windows laptop, Android phone and iPad, because it lives in the manager’s encrypted vault rather than in one company’s ecosystem.
Platform keychain or password manager: pros and cons
Platform keychains (iCloud Keychain, Google Password Manager, Windows Hello) are free, built in and very easy to use — but they work best when every device you own comes from the same company.
Third-party password managers work across every operating system and browser, handle passwords, passkeys, notes and 2FA codes together, and make sharing straightforward — at the cost of another app and, for premium features, a subscription.
How to start using passkeys today
- Pick where your passkeys will live — ideally the same password manager you already use.
- Start with your most important accounts: email, your Apple, Google or Microsoft account, and banking if it’s offered.
- When a site offers “Create a passkey”, accept it and let your manager save it.
- Keep the existing password stored and strong for now, since many sites still use it for recovery.
- Review your vault every few months — most managers now show which sites support passkeys.
The verdict
Passkeys are the best sign-in technology most people will use this decade, but they are an addition to a password manager, not a replacement for it. If you don’t have one yet, start with our best password manager guide or the best free options.
